Creamy Roasted Red Pepper Orzo with Poached Lobster

An elegant, forgiving dinner for date night—and beyond

Some meals are about showing off.
This one is about showing love.

I wanted a dish that feels special enough for Valentine’s Day or an anniversary, but still makes sense for a home cook who doesn’t want to spend the entire evening babysitting a pan. Something elegant, comforting, and a little luxurious—without the stress.

That’s where this roasted red pepper orzo comes in.

It delivers the creamy, restaurant-style feel people love about risotto, but with far more forgiveness. The orzo cooks evenly, the roasted red peppers bring natural sweetness and depth, and the whole dish gives you room to breathe. From there, you choose the protein that fits the moment.

Lobster is the classic choice—and the one this dish was built around—but shrimp or scallops slide in beautifully when you want something a little more casual.

Cook once.
Choose your moment.
Choose your protein.

Why Orzo Over Risotto

(A quick word for the home cook)

Risotto is great—when you want a project.

Orzo gives you the same creamy payoff with:

• Less stirring
• More even cooking
• A wider margin for error

You still build flavor the right way—aromatics, toasted pasta, warm stock—but you’re not chained to the stove. That’s the difference between a dish that looks impressive and one you’ll actually make again.

 

Choose Your Protein

(Primary focus: lobster)

 
Lobster — The Occasion Pick

If you’re cooking this for Valentine’s Day or a true celebration, lobster is the move.

Poaching keeps it tender, controlled, and stress-free. Gentle heat lets the sweetness shine, and a butter-forward poach quietly ties into the richness of the orzo without overpowering it.

Why it works

• Luxurious without being flashy
• Very forgiving compared to grilling or broiling
• Sweet lobster + savory red pepper orzo is a classic balance

This is the version that feels like a restaurant plate—but cooked calmly at home.

 

Shrimp — The Smart Alternative

Shrimp keeps all the elegance with less commitment.

A quick pan-sear with butter, garlic, and lemon turns this into a weeknight-friendly dinner that still feels special. Same base, same technique, different energy.

Why it works

• Faster cook time
• Easier sourcing
• More budget-friendly 

 

Scallops — The Chef’s Flex

Scallops are the quiet power move here.

They cook fast, plate beautifully, and bring a natural sweetness that pairs perfectly with the roasted red pepper base.

How to do it

• Use large, dry-packed sea scallops
• Pat very dry, season well
• Sear hard in a hot pan with oil
• Finish with butter and lemon

Golden crust, creamy orzo underneath, done.

  

Recipe: Creamy Roasted Red Pepper Orzo with Poached Lobster

Serves 2 (comfortably indulgent)

 
Ingredients

Roasted Red Pepper Orzo

• 1 cup dry orzo
• 1-2 large roasted red peppers, drained
• 1 small shallot, finely diced
• 2 cloves garlic, minced
• 1 tbsp tomato paste
• 2½ cups warm chicken or seafood stock
• ¼ cup grated Parmesan, plus more to finish
• 1 tbsp butter
• Olive oil
• Lemon juice, to taste
• Sea salt and fresh cracked pepper

Poached Lobster (Primary Version)

• 2 lobster tails (5–6 oz each), flesh removed from shells
• 1 stick of unsalted butter
• 1 small shallot, sliced
• 1 clove garlic, smashed
• 1 strip lemon peel
• Water or light stock, just enough to cover

 

Method

 
1. Prep First

 

Read the recipe. Chop everything. Warm the stock. Calm cooking starts before the pan is hot.

 
2. Build the Roasted Red Pepper Base
 

Blend the roasted red peppers until smooth. Set aside.

 
3. Start the Orzo

 

In a wide sauté pan, heat olive oil over medium heat.

Add shallot and cook until soft, 2–3 minutes.

Add garlic and tomato paste; cook until the paste darkens slightly and smells rich.

Stir in the orzo and toast for about 30–45 seconds.

 
4. Make It Creamy

Add the red pepper purée and half the warm stock. Bring to a gentle simmer.

As the orzo absorbs liquid, add more stock a little at a time, stirring occasionally—not constantly. Cook until tender and creamy, about 10–12 minutes.

Finish with butter, Parmesan, lemon juice, salt, and pepper. Keep warm.

 
5. Poach the Lobster

In a small saucepan, combine butter, shallot, garlic, lemon peel, and enough water or stock to just cover the lobster once added.

Bring to a bare simmer—no boil—and make sure the butter is completely melted. Using an instant read thermometer, keep the liquid between 160 and 180 degrees F. Add lobster tails and cook gently until just opaque, 5–8 minutes. Pull them early if anything. Overcooked lobster is heartbreak.

Remove, rest briefly, and slice if desired.

 
6. Plate

Spoon orzo onto warm plates. Nestle lobster on top. Finish with extra Parmesan and microgreens or thin lemon slices.

Serve immediately. Pour wine. Take a breath.

 

 

Final Thoughts

This is one of those dishes that looks like you worked much harder than you did. The technique is sound, the flavors are classic, and the structure is flexible enough to grow with you.

Whether it’s lobster for Valentine’s Day, shrimp on a Tuesday, or scallops when you want to flex a little—this one earns a permanent spot in the rotation.

 

As always, reach out to The Small Town Chef with any questions or comments. We look forward to hearing from you.

Copyright © 2026 The Small Town Chef - All Rights Reserved.